Skip to main content
Use case

What to send after a deal goes cold.

Most lost-deal emails get ignored because the ask is wrong. A voice link costs the prospect sixty seconds from their phone. That is a different ask, and it gets answered.

Try it free
No login required for your prospects

The short answer

Send a single-question Magic Link within 48 hours of the deal going cold. The prospect clicks it, records a 60-second voice note in any browser, and does not need to log in or accept cookies. You get a transcript and an AI summary in your dashboard. Read five of those side by side and the pattern that killed those deals becomes obvious.
60 sec
all it costs the prospect
No login
no cookies, no commitment
40–60%
average reply rate

Why exit surveys do not work

The problem is not that prospects have no opinion. Most of them have a very clear one. The problem is the ask itself. A "please complete our 3-minute survey" email lands in an inbox already full of things that person chose not to deal with. It asks them to open a form, read questions, think, type, proofread, and submit, for a company they already decided not to work with. Almost nobody does that.

A voice link flips the equation. One tap. One question. Speak for sixty seconds from their phone. Done. No form, no account, no cookies, no trace in any system. The friction is low enough that the decision to respond becomes a different kind of calculation, and most people who liked you, even a little, will say yes to that.

Be honest about one thing though: if the relationship ended badly, no format will get a reply. Voice links work well with warm lost deals where the prospect went another direction, not with contacts who felt misled or wasted time. Know the difference before you send.

The playbook

Four steps. They go in order.

  1. 1

    Send within 48 hours

    The decision is freshest right after it is made. A week later, the prospect has moved on mentally and your message arrives as a relic from a project they closed. Send within two days of hearing the no, or within two days of going silent if they ghosted.

  2. 2

    Ask one specific question

    Not "can you tell us more about your decision?" That is too open and too much work. Something specific: "What would have needed to be different for this to be a yes?" or "What made you go with the other option?" One question they can answer in sixty seconds without having to think hard about structure.

  3. 3

    Frame it so they feel safe

    The prospect said no. They are probably bracing for a counter-pitch. Defuse that in the email body: "No pitch, no follow-up. Just sixty seconds if you're willing." Then the Magic Link. That framing signals you respect the no. It is also just true: the link does not capture their email or add them to anything.

  4. 4

    Read the pattern across five to ten deals

    One lost-deal response is anecdote. Five is signal. Ten is close to fact. Read the AI summaries side by side. The thing that comes up three times in a row is not a coincidence: it is a product gap, a pricing problem, or a positioning failure worth fixing.

What question to ask

This is the hardest part. The wrong question gets a polite non-answer. The right one gets the thing they said internally when they made the decision. Below are four that tend to work, with a note on why each one is constructed the way it is.

"What would have made this a yes?"

Forward-looking, not accusatory. Asks them to imagine a better version of your product, not to criticize the one they saw.

"What did the other option have that tipped the decision?"

Direct and specific. Gives you a concrete competitive data point. Works best when you already know who they went with.

"What was the thing that felt missing or unclear?"

Surfaces friction points that might be fixable. Often uncovers messaging failures as much as product gaps.

"If you had to explain to a colleague why you went elsewhere, what would you say?"

Forces them to articulate it simply. The answer is close to what they actually said when they made the decision internally.

Pick one. Only one. Multiple questions in a single voice link raise the effort bar and reduce the reply rate. If a prospect's first answer makes you want to dig deeper, send a follow-up link with question two.

Related pages

Where lost-deal feedback fits in a broader async voice workflow.

Comparison

Alternatives to discovery calls

When async voice earns its place in the sales flow, and when you still need the live call.

ICP

HeySpeak for consultants

Use async voice as the second touch in your sales flow. Worked examples.

Common questions

Won't prospects just ignore this too?
Some will. But the ask is fundamentally different from a survey link. A voice note takes sixty seconds from their phone, no form, no typing, no commitment. Reply rates on warm lost deals with a well-framed message tend to land between 30 and 50 percent. That is higher than most cold outreach, and these are people who already know you.
What is the best question to ask a lost deal?
The most reliable one is "What would have made this a yes?" It is forward-looking and non-accusatory, so it does not put the prospect on the defensive. If you know who they went with, "What did [competitor] have that tipped it?" gives you sharper competitive data. Avoid open-ended prompts like "tell us about your experience", which require too much effort to answer well.
Should I mention that it is recorded?
Yes, briefly. Something like "just a 60-second voice note, I'll listen and use it to improve" is honest and sets expectations. Most people are fine with it. The ones who are not would not have answered anyway.
How do I use the feedback once I have it?
Read the AI summaries for all your lost deals in one sitting. Look for the thing that comes up repeatedly: that is the signal. Then decide: is this a product gap, a pricing problem, or a messaging issue? Each one has a different fix. Do not act on a single response. Act on a pattern.
Does the prospect need to install anything or create an account?
No. The Magic Link opens in any browser on any device. They tap record, speak for up to sixty seconds, and hit send. No app, no login, no cookies, no account. They are not entering your CRM or agreeing to future contact. Just answering one question.

Turn lost deals into product insights.

Five free responses to start. Setup takes under a minute.

Create your first Magic Link